My Disability Studies Blackboard
Wednesday, November 20, 2024
The 'slippery slope' argument against assisted dying
The "slippery slope" argument against assisted dying posits that legalizing assisted dying could lead to unintended and potentially harmful consequences. Here are some key points to consider:
Broadening Eligibility: Initially, assisted dying might be limited to those with terminal illnesses. Over time, however, criteria could expand to include individuals with chronic illnesses, disabilities, or mental health conditions. This broadening could lead to vulnerable populations feeling pressured to choose assisted dying.
Erosion of Trust: The trust between patients and healthcare providers could be eroded. Patients might fear that doctors will recommend assisted dying as a viable option when other treatments are available. This could undermine the fundamental role of healthcare providers to heal and care.
Societal Pressure: Legalizing assisted dying might create societal pressure on the elderly, disabled, or chronically ill individuals to end their lives to avoid being a burden on their families or the healthcare system. This pressure could distort the voluntary nature of the decision.
Moral and Ethical Concerns: The ethical landscape of medicine is built on the principle of "do no harm." Introducing assisted dying challenges this principle and could lead to ethical dilemmas where the value of life becomes subjective, based on quality of life judgments.
Safeguard Erosion: While initial laws might have strict safeguards, there is a risk that these could be eroded over time, making it easier for misuse or abuse to occur. This erosion could lead to cases where individuals are assisted in dying without thorough consideration of all other options and supports.
These points illustrate how the slippery slope argument reflects concerns about the long-term societal, ethical, and medical implications of legalizing assisted dying.
Saturday, September 21, 2024
Frozen Festivities: The Unchanging £10 Christmas Bonus for UK Benefit Claimants
The issue of the £10 Christmas Bonus for people on benefits in the UK, which has remained unchanged for nearly 50 years, highlights a significant problem in the way society and government view and treat those who are economically disadvantaged. This essay will explore why the stagnant value of this bonus can be seen as a sign of contempt for poor people.
Historical Context and Current Value
The £10 Christmas Bonus was introduced in 1972 as a gesture to help those on benefits during the festive season. At the time, £10 had considerable purchasing power. However, due to inflation and the rising cost of living, the value of £10 has significantly diminished over the past five decades. Today, it is worth only about 76 pence in real terms. This stark devaluation underscores the failure to adjust the bonus in line with economic changes, reflecting a lack of consideration for the financial struggles faced by those on benefits.
Symbolic Gesture vs. Practical Support
While the original intent of the Christmas Bonus was to provide additional support during a financially demanding time of year, its current value renders it almost meaningless. The failure to increase the bonus over the years suggests that it has become more of a symbolic gesture rather than a practical form of assistance. This can be interpreted as a lack of genuine concern for the well-being of poor people, as the government has not taken steps to ensure that the bonus remains a useful and supportive measure.
Friday, September 20, 2024
The Velocity of Money and the Impact of Welfare Benefits on the Economy
The velocity of money is a fundamental concept in economics that measures the rate at which money circulates within an economy. It is defined as the frequency with which a unit of currency is used to purchase goods and services within a given time period. The velocity of money is crucial because it helps to understand the efficiency of money in facilitating economic transactions and its impact on overall economic activity.
Understanding the Velocity of Money
The velocity of money is typically calculated using the formula:
V = \frac{GDP}{M}
where ( V ) represents the velocity of money, ( GDP ) is the gross domestic product, and ( M ) is the money supply. A higher velocity indicates that each unit of currency is being used more frequently to purchase goods and services, suggesting a more active and dynamic economy. Conversely, a lower velocity implies that money is changing hands less frequently, which may indicate economic stagnation or a lack of consumer confidence.
Several factors influence the velocity of money, including interest rates, inflation, consumer confidence, and the overall economic environment. For instance, during periods of economic growth, consumers and businesses are more likely to spend money, leading to a higher velocity. In contrast, during economic downturns, individuals and firms may hoard cash, resulting in a lower velocity.
Welfare Benefits and Their Economic Impact
Welfare benefits are government-provided financial assistance programs designed to support individuals and families in need. These benefits can take various forms, including unemployment benefits, food assistance, housing subsidies, and direct cash transfers. The primary goal of welfare benefits is to alleviate poverty, reduce inequality, and provide a safety net for vulnerable populations.
When welfare benefits are actively spent into the economy, they can have a significant impact on economic activity and the velocity of money. Here are some key ways in which welfare benefits influence the economy:
Increased Consumer Spending: Welfare benefits provide recipients with additional income, which they are likely to spend on essential goods and services. This increased consumer spending can stimulate demand for products and services, leading to higher sales for businesses and potentially boosting economic growth.
Multiplier Effect: The money spent by welfare recipients can have a multiplier effect on the economy. As recipients spend their benefits, businesses experience increased revenue, which can lead to higher employment and wages. The additional income earned by workers is then spent on further goods and services, creating a positive feedback loop that amplifies the initial economic impact.
Stabilizing the Economy: Welfare benefits can act as automatic stabilizers during economic downturns. When the economy contracts, more individuals may become eligible for welfare benefits, which helps to maintain consumer spending levels and prevent a deeper recession. This stabilizing effect can help to smooth out economic fluctuations and support a more resilient economy.
Reducing Inequality: By providing financial assistance to low-income individuals and families, welfare benefits can help to reduce income inequality. This redistribution of income can lead to a more equitable society and ensure that a broader segment of the population has access to basic necessities.
Conclusion
The velocity of money is a critical indicator of economic activity, reflecting the frequency with which money circulates within an economy. Welfare benefits, when actively spent, can significantly influence the velocity of money and overall economic performance. By increasing consumer spending, generating a multiplier effect, stabilizing the economy, and reducing inequality, welfare benefits play a vital role in promoting economic well-being and social stability. Understanding the interplay between the velocity of money and welfare benefits is essential for policymakers aiming to foster a healthy and inclusive economy.
Friday, December 22, 2023
A Personal Message from Disability Rights UK this Christmas
In solidarity with you, our movement together is stronger
As we come to the end of the year, I want to express my solidarity with you all. I know that this year has been a difficult one for so many in our community. Your lived experience and voices continue to be the force behind our collective efforts. We have a rich history as a movement of coming together and challenging the injustice and inequality.
The cost-of-living crisis is leaving many of us without heated homes this winter, a scandal beyond words. All of our communities, up and down the UK, are experiencing harsher living conditions as a result – and unsurprisingly, Disabled people are being hit the hardest. We should never be forced to choose between lifesaving and affirming treatments, and having food, heating or social care.
All of us at Disability Rights UK are committed to the fight for better, for equal rights and with you this will never waiver. Your voice behind our collective demands is important, I hope you will stay in touch and join us.
As we close the year, module 2 of the Covid-19 Inquiry has just closed. We are proud of our contributions to the Inquiry. Our lawyers penetrating questions helped to lay bare the Government’s dismissal of our lives as Disabled people throughout the pandemic. We won’t stop until there is justice and accountability. This can never happen again.
This year in response to the attack on our rights Disabled People’s Organisations from across England worked together to create a Disabled People’s Manifesto. It is packed full of radical reforms and transformative policies to improve the lives of everyone in the UK – an inclusive society works for everyone. The manifesto was launched at the People’s History Museum in Manchester, with Disabled activists and organisers across generations. The wealth of knowledge, history and passion was inspiring.
Thank you for your continued support of Disability Rights UK and for being such an important part of this movement. I look forward to the coming year and working together for change.
A final note from me: we know Christmas can be an especially difficult or lonely time of the year for some of us. As DR UK closes from December 22nd to January 2nd, I wanted to let you know of some support services and helplines available throughout this time:
Age UK
Advice Line open 8am-7pm, every day of the year. Call them on 0800 678 1602
Trussell Trust
Their Help through Hardship line is open 5 days a week, 9am-5pm. They will be closed on Christmas public holidays. Call them on 0808 208 2138
Switchboard
Their helpline for LGBT people is open 10am-10pm, every day of the year. Call them on 0800 0119 100
Samaritans
Their helpline is open 24/7, every day of the year. You can call them on 116 123, or for their Welsh language line, 0808 164 123.
The Silver Line
Provides support for anyone over the age of 55 who may feel lonely or isolated. Their helpline is open every day of the year, 24 hours a day. Call them on 0800 4 70 80 90
Beat
Their eating disorder helpline is open every day of the year, 1pm-9pm on weekdays and 5pm-9pm on weekends and bank holidays. You can call them on 0808 801 0677 if you're in England, or 0808 801 0433 in Wales.
Mind
Their helplines are open every weekday from 10am-6pm. They are closed on 25th and 26th of December and 1st of January.
You can find out the numbers and more information about different organisations and helplines from Mind's webpage.
Disability Rights UK's helplines will be closed the week beginning the 25th December, until January 2nd.
From the whole team at Disability Rights UK, we send you our festive wishes, our solidarity, and our commitment to keep fighting for a world where we have justice and rights as Disabled people.
Kind regards,
Kamran Mallick signature
Kamran Mallick
CEO, Disability Rights UK
Tuesday, April 18, 2023
The Tory government is acting as pimps: The link between benefit sanctions and prostitution
There is evidence that suggests a link between benefit sanctions and prostitution. For example, a report from the English Collective of Prostitutes documented how cuts to single mothers' benefits have had an impact on the rise in prostitution ³. Additionally, MPs launched an inquiry into "survival sex" where benefit claimants impoverished by universal credit or sanctions have turned to prostitution to pay rent or feed their families ².
Source: Conversation with Bing, 4/18/2023
(1) SUBMISSION TO THE UNITED NATIONS SPECIAL RAPPORTEUR ON EXTREME POVERTY .... https://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Issues/EPoverty/UnitedKingdom/2018/NGOS/English_CollectiveofProstitutes.pdf.
(2) MPs to launch inquiry into ‘survival sex’ by benefit claimants. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2019/mar/19/mps-to-launch-inquiry-into-survival-sex-by-benefit-claimants.
(3) The Impacts of Benefit Sanctions: A Scoping Review of the Quantitative .... https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-social-policy/article/impacts-of-benefit-sanctions-a-scoping-review-of-the-quantitative-research-evidence/9272BC857236795930DCD6AB7B8E04A1.
(4) Criminalize vs. Decriminalize Sex Work: The Debate Continues. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/modern-day-slavery/202207/criminalize-vs-decriminalize-sex-work-the-debate-continues.
Sunday, April 16, 2023
An AI composes a sonnet blaming successive Tory governments in the UK for benefit sanction deaths
Oh, Tories, how you've caused such needless pain,
With policies that hurt the poor and weak,
Your cuts and sanctions, each one more insane,
Have caused so many tears and so much bleak.
The benefit system, once a source of aid,
Has become a tool to punish and shame,
For those who need it most, it's now a raid,
A game that's rigged and stacked in your own name.
You claim to care for all, but that's a lie,
For those who suffer most, you turn away,
Your hearts are cold, your conscience will not pry,
You let them die, and then you look away.
Oh Tories, how you've caused such needless grief,
May history judge you harshly, beyond belief.
Friday, April 14, 2023
Why sanctioning sick and disabled benefit claimants during a pandemic, recession, and banking crisis can be considered immoral
Sanctioning sick and disabled benefit claimants during a pandemic, recession, and banking crisis can be considered immoral for several reasons.
Firstly, benefit sanctions are punishment fines whereby claimants’ benefits are docked for at least a month for supposed infringements¹. This can have a negative effect on claimants’ health and finances¹. In fact, DWP staff have admitted to inflicting psychological harm on claimants².
Secondly, there is no evidence that benefit sanctions incentivize people to get work¹. A report by the National Audit Office in 2016 found that there was no evidence that sanctions work or that the system is saving the taxpayer money⁵.
Thirdly, during a pandemic, recession, and banking crisis, people are already facing financial difficulties. Sanctioning their benefits would only add to their hardship.
In conclusion, sanctioning sick and disabled benefit claimants during a pandemic, recession, and banking crisis can be considered immoral because it can harm their health and finances without any evidence of effectiveness.
Source: Conversation with Bing, 4/14/2023
(1) DWP ordered to release ‘sensitive’ research into effects of benefit .... https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/mar/14/dwp-ordered-to-release-sensitive-research-into-effects-of-benefit-sanctions.
(2) DWP staff admit inflicting ‘psychological harm’ on claimants during .... https://www.disabilitynewsservice.com/dwp-staff-admit-inflicting-psychological-harm-on-claimants-during-coalition-years/.
(3) Benefit sanctions are punishing disabled people for the sake of it. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/feb/20/sanctions-disabled-people-claimants-tough-love.
(4) Disabled people denied benefit uplift during pandemic because it would .... https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/disability-benefit-uplift-universal-credit-dwp-it-system-b1724260.html.
(5) Opinion | Disabled Americans Are Losing a Lifeline - New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/14/opinion/supplemental-security-income-ssa-disability.html.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)